1. Missing Communication with Coaches and Recruiters

Many student-athletes focus solely on their academic applications and neglect the recruitment process. Not reaching out to coaches early enough or failing to showcase your athletic achievements can cost you scholarship opportunities.

How to avoid this mistake:

• Contact coaches as early as possible with highlight videos, stats, and achievements.

• Maintain consistent communication and follow up on emails.

• Be proactive in sending updates on your athletic and academic progress.

2. Underestimating NCAA and NAIA Eligibility Requirements

Different athletic divisions (NCAA, NAIA, NJCAA) have specific eligibility requirements that student-athletes must meet. Many international students fail to check if they qualify under academic and amateurism rules.

How to avoid this mistake:

• Research the eligibility rules for your desired division.

• Register with the NCAA or NAIA Eligibility Center if required.

• Work with your school counselors to ensure your academic records meet the standards.

3. Not Preparing for Standardized Tests and Language Proficiency

Some student-athletes assume their athletic abilities alone will secure them admission, but they still need to meet the school’s academic standards, including SAT, ACT, TOEFL, or IELTS scores.

How to avoid this mistake:

• Find out which tests are required by your target schools.

• Schedule your tests early to allow time for retakes if needed.

• Take practice tests and consider prep courses to improve your scores.

4. Ignoring Scholarship and Financial Aid Opportunities

Many student-athletes assume they will receive a full-ride scholarship, but not all athletic scholarships cover full tuition, and some schools offer limited funding.

How to avoid this mistake:

• Research different types of scholarships, including academic and athletic aid.

• Apply for additional financial aid and grants if needed.

• Discuss scholarship options with coaches during recruitment conversations.

5. Choosing a College Based Only on Athletics

While playing at a high-level program is important, student-athletes should also consider academics, campus life, and career opportunities after college.

How to avoid this mistake:

• Research academic programs and career support at each college.

• Talk to current student-athletes about their experience.

• Make sure the school is a good fit beyond sports, considering location, culture, and academic offerings.

Applying to U.S. colleges as an international student-athlete requires careful planning and research. By avoiding these common mistakes—failing to communicate with coaches, ignoring eligibility rules, neglecting test preparation, misjudging financial aid, and choosing a college based only on athletics—you can increase your chances of a successful recruitment and academic experience.